1 00:00:07.575 --> 00:00:12.575 Chapter 2 explains the basic virtues 2 00:00:12.925 --> 00:00:15.175 As in basic virtues, 3 00:00:15.175 --> 00:00:18.275 he uses the term ‘Cardinal Virtues' 4 00:00:18.725 --> 00:00:24.375 Here, ‘Cardinal’ does not mean a Catholic ‘Cardinal’ 5 00:00:24.375 --> 00:00:27.625 but rather something fundamental 6 00:00:27.625 --> 00:00:34.075 These virtues are the core moral capacities God has given humanity 7 00:00:34.075 --> 00:00:38.475 Despite human fallenness due to sin, 8 00:00:39.025 --> 00:00:42.526 these virtues remain 9 00:00:42.526 --> 00:00:45.576 within even fallen humanity, 10 00:00:45.576 --> 00:00:47.826 under God’s common grace 11 00:00:48.076 --> 00:00:51.476 Of the seven virtues, 12 00:00:51.476 --> 00:00:55.626 (Prudence, temperance, justice, and fortitude) he explained the four 'Cardinal' 13 00:00:55.626 --> 00:01:00.226 (Faith, hope, and love) and three 'Theological' 14 00:01:00.226 --> 00:01:04.876 The theological virtues refer to the three virtues 15 00:01:04.876 --> 00:01:09.826 experienced by born-again Christians, 16 00:01:09.826 --> 00:01:13.626 by the power of the Holy Spirit and the blood of Jesus Christ 17 00:01:13.626 --> 00:01:19.626 These are faith, hope, and love 18 00:01:20.126 --> 00:01:22.426 In Chapter 2, Lewis focuses on 19 00:01:22.426 --> 00:01:24.076 the four fundamental virtues 20 00:01:24.076 --> 00:01:27.476 out of the seven 21 00:01:28.176 --> 00:01:31.226 The first virtue in the chapter 22 00:01:31.226 --> 00:01:35.726 is called prudence 23 00:01:35.726 --> 00:01:37.576 Prudence is 24 00:01:37.776 --> 00:01:42.776 an essential judgment for living 25 00:01:42.776 --> 00:01:46.926 as a human being, or practical common sense 26 00:01:46.926 --> 00:01:51.827 So it is a practical common sense 27 00:01:52.327 --> 00:01:55.527 Prudence for humans 28 00:01:55.527 --> 00:01:57.427 is to foresee 29 00:01:57.427 --> 00:02:02.477 the consequences of one’s actions 30 00:02:02.477 --> 00:02:07.227 This is prudence as a practical common sense 31 00:02:07.227 --> 00:02:10.927 Jesus’s instruction to become like children 32 00:02:10.927 --> 00:02:15.577 refers to a pure-hearted state, 33 00:02:15.577 --> 00:02:20.177 not to a reckless action of a chile 34 00:02:20.577 --> 00:02:24.927 without moral discernment or foresight 35 00:02:24.927 --> 00:02:30.327 Growth in the discernment, or prudence 36 00:02:30.327 --> 00:02:32.727 that God grants us 37 00:02:32.727 --> 00:02:36.927 is one of His great blessings to humanity 38 00:02:36.927 --> 00:02:39.627 While prudence is 39 00:02:39.627 --> 00:02:42.277 not exclusive to Christians, 40 00:02:42.277 --> 00:02:45.627 history shows that believers 41 00:02:45.627 --> 00:02:49.377 who receive the grace of Jesus Christ 42 00:02:49.377 --> 00:02:54.227 and are reborn by the blood of His cross 43 00:02:54.227 --> 00:02:58.127 experience a deeper, 44 00:02:58.127 --> 00:03:01.077 maturing prudence as time passes 45 00:03:02.527 --> 00:03:04.828 Comparing the prudence of believers 46 00:03:04.828 --> 00:03:08.428 with non-believers reveals 47 00:03:08.428 --> 00:03:12.928 that faith brings an enriched discernment 48 00:03:12.928 --> 00:03:16.778 Therefore, true belief in Jesus itself 49 00:03:16.778 --> 00:03:20.278 can be seen as an education 50 00:03:20.478 --> 00:03:24.678 The second moral aspect is temperance, 51 00:03:24.678 --> 00:03:27.878 which is the quality of moderation 52 00:03:28.428 --> 00:03:32.378 This does not mean complete abstinence 53 00:03:32.378 --> 00:03:37.378 practicing moderation and staying within limits 54 00:03:37.378 --> 00:03:40.528 It aligns with the ‘self-control’ 55 00:03:40.828 --> 00:03:44.928 as a fruit of the Spirit 56 00:03:45.628 --> 00:03:48.128 Importantly, temperance does not mean 57 00:03:48.128 --> 00:03:52.128 imposing our abstentions on others 58 00:03:52.578 --> 00:03:55.628 As we enjoy various aspects of life, 59 00:03:55.628 --> 00:04:00.778 like sports, movies, and other forms of entertainment, 60 00:04:00.778 --> 00:04:05.578 it’s essential to maintain moderation 61 00:04:05.578 --> 00:04:08.678 Lewis emphasizes that 62 00:04:08.678 --> 00:04:13.578 temperance is not about living 63 00:04:13.578 --> 00:04:17.128 in complete isolation from culture 64 00:04:17.629 --> 00:04:19.529 Since he himself was 65 00:04:19.529 --> 00:04:21.029 a writer of literature 66 00:04:21.029 --> 00:04:23.979 and many fairy tales, 67 00:04:23.979 --> 00:04:27.479 he argues that viewing 68 00:04:27.479 --> 00:04:29.929 cultural activities such as theatre 69 00:04:29.929 --> 00:04:32.729 as sinful is misguided 70 00:04:32.729 --> 00:04:34.879 It’s the content that matters, 71 00:04:34.879 --> 00:04:38.079 not rejecting culture itself, 72 00:04:38.079 --> 00:04:42.229 which is not what temperance is about 73 00:04:42.229 --> 00:04:45.129 In this area, C.S. Lewis’s stance 74 00:04:45.129 --> 00:04:47.079 on alcohol may be controversial 75 00:04:47.079 --> 00:04:48.929 among Korean Christians 76 00:04:49.179 --> 00:04:52.179 Lewis advocates for moderate drinking 77 00:04:52.179 --> 00:04:57.279 rather than complete abstinence, 78 00:04:57.279 --> 00:05:00.179 which may differ from a biblical viewpoint 79 00:05:00.879 --> 00:05:03.729 Considering the Bible as a whole, 80 00:05:03.729 --> 00:05:07.679 there are more commands encouraging abstinence 81 00:05:07.679 --> 00:05:09.929 Jesus turning water into wine 82 00:05:09.929 --> 00:05:12.329 does not justify drinking 83 00:05:12.329 --> 00:05:15.179 In the New Testament era, 84 00:05:15.179 --> 00:05:17.079 wine served as a key beverage 85 00:05:17.079 --> 00:05:22.879 due to scarce clean water 86 00:05:22.879 --> 00:05:24.379 in Jesus' time 87 00:05:26.979 --> 00:05:29.579 Today, with less need for alcohol 88 00:05:29.579 --> 00:05:33.180 with ample access to clean water, 89 00:05:33.180 --> 00:05:36.030 interpreting Scripture’s overall context 90 00:05:36.030 --> 00:05:40.330 suggests a stronger command toward abstinence 91 00:05:40.680 --> 00:05:44.880 Thus, while C.S. Lewis, J.R.R. Tolkien, 92 00:05:44.880 --> 00:05:50.330 and other writers enjoyed conversations over drinks in pubs, 93 00:05:50.330 --> 00:05:53.030 applying their cultural approach 94 00:05:53.030 --> 00:05:57.130 of moderation, rather than abstinence, 95 00:05:57.130 --> 00:05:59.430 directly to today’s context 96 00:05:59.430 --> 00:06:02.630 may be challenging 97 00:06:02.630 --> 00:06:06.680 Is moderate drinking truly feasible? 98 00:06:06.680 --> 00:06:12.780 Unless for medicinal purposes 99 00:06:12.780 --> 00:06:15.680 or specific health issues, 100 00:06:15.680 --> 00:06:19.430 frequent or habitual drinking 101 00:06:19.430 --> 00:06:21.630 often leads to alcoholism 102 00:06:21.630 --> 00:06:25.130 or serious health risks 103 00:06:25.130 --> 00:06:27.530 This lacks proper prudence 104 00:06:27.530 --> 00:06:30.030 Therefore, this area 105 00:06:30.030 --> 00:06:33.030 requires careful and prudence on our part 106 00:06:34.030 --> 00:06:38.380 The third cardinal virtue is justice 107 00:06:38.380 --> 00:06:41.380 This differs from legal justice 108 00:06:41.530 --> 00:06:43.430 (Encompasses more than legal justice) A ‘not guilty’ verdict in court 109 00:06:43.430 --> 00:06:47.981 (Includes what we call fairness today) is not always an actual innocence 110 00:06:48.381 --> 00:06:49.181 Justice does not only refer 111 00:06:49.181 --> 00:06:52.681 to those convicted and sentenced to prison 112 00:06:52.681 --> 00:06:56.031 Many injustices occur 113 00:06:56.031 --> 00:06:58.331 even if one is acquitted in court 114 00:06:58.581 --> 00:07:00.681 Here, justice includes 115 00:07:00.681 --> 00:07:08.831 honesty, fairness, integrity, and faithfulness in keeping promises, 116 00:07:08.831 --> 00:07:11.231 qualities essential to our live 117 00:07:11.631 --> 00:07:13.631 God is righteous, 118 00:07:13.631 --> 00:07:17.681 honest, faithful, and trustworthy 119 00:07:17.681 --> 00:07:21.681 When our lives reflect such justice, 120 00:07:21.681 --> 00:07:24.781 we can truly say we are made in ‘the image of God' 121 00:07:25.431 --> 00:07:30.781 The fourth virtue is fortitude, 122 00:07:30.781 --> 00:07:36.231 meaning resilience or steadfastness 123 00:07:36.481 --> 00:07:39.181 It is courage in pain, 124 00:07:39.181 --> 00:07:41.531 or courage in adversity 125 00:07:41.531 --> 00:07:46.081 It is also the courage 126 00:07:46.081 --> 00:07:48.231 to overcome adversity 127 00:07:48.581 --> 00:07:51.331 It is the strength to endure 128 00:07:51.331 --> 00:07:54.781 and overcome hardship 129 00:07:54.781 --> 00:07:56.881 as well as adversity 130 00:07:57.131 --> 00:07:58.732 Let's go over the four again 131 00:07:58.732 --> 00:08:02.232 First, prudence 132 00:08:02.232 --> 00:08:05.782 Second, temperance 133 00:08:05.782 --> 00:08:08.832 Third, justice 134 00:08:08.832 --> 00:08:10.932 And fourth, fortitude 135 00:08:10.932 --> 00:08:14.082 It is the courage to persevere through hardship 136 00:08:14.082 --> 00:08:16.582 These are fundamental virtues 137 00:08:16.982 --> 00:08:20.732 present in all humanity, 138 00:08:20.732 --> 00:08:28.182 even in those not reborn through Jesus Christ 139 00:08:28.182 --> 00:08:30.982 So these are virtues of humans 140 00:08:30.982 --> 00:08:33.682 Let us remember Lewis' point, 141 00:08:33.682 --> 00:08:37.432 that in those transformed by the Holy Spirit 142 00:08:37.432 --> 00:08:43.382 through Jesus Christ, these moral virtues 143 00:08:43.382 --> 00:08:48.182 can mature to an even greater degree 144 00:08:48.732 --> 00:08:51.832 Lewis emphasizes that possessing these 145 00:08:51.832 --> 00:08:56.932 moral virtues or traits is 146 00:08:56.932 --> 00:08:58.982 not a requirement for entering 147 00:08:58.982 --> 00:09:00.432 the eternal Kingdom of God 148 00:09:01.132 --> 00:09:03.382 What Lewis means is, 149 00:09:03.382 --> 00:09:05.882 If these qualities are 150 00:09:05.882 --> 00:09:10.132 not cultivated and ingrained within, 151 00:09:10.132 --> 00:09:12.882 we will never 152 00:09:12.882 --> 00:09:16.483 truly find happiness, even if we receive 153 00:09:16.483 --> 00:09:18.283 all God’s blessings on this earth 154 00:09:18.683 --> 00:09:22.133 Even if God allows a taste 155 00:09:22.133 --> 00:09:26.533 of heaven on earth, we would be unable to fully enjoy it 156 00:09:26.533 --> 00:09:31.983 We would be unable to experience happiness, despite the circumstance 157 00:09:32.283 --> 00:09:37.583 Ultimately, humans must be deeply moral 158 00:09:37.583 --> 00:09:39.383 to enjoy the happiness 159 00:09:40.233 --> 00:09:43.083 True happiness from God is 160 00:09:43.083 --> 00:09:45.033 only attainable when humans live 161 00:09:45.033 --> 00:09:48.733 according to the purpose for which God created them 162 00:09:50.233 --> 00:09:51.233 Mere Christianity Book 3 Christian Behavior 163 00:09:51.233 --> 00:09:56.133 Chapter 3 Social Morality 164 00:09:56.533 --> 00:10:01.133 Chapter 3 is about social morality 165 00:10:04.383 --> 00:10:05.833 Among the seven fundamental virtues, 166 00:10:05.833 --> 00:10:07.483 faith, hope, and love 167 00:10:07.483 --> 00:10:10.083 will be featured in later chapters 168 00:10:10.083 --> 00:10:13.183 This chapter is about social morality 169 00:10:13.183 --> 00:10:16.783 because for the three parts of morality, 170 00:10:16.783 --> 00:10:21.633 many people are immersed and interested 171 00:10:21.633 --> 00:10:23.433 in the interpersonal relationship 172 00:10:23.433 --> 00:10:25.584 That's why Lewis dedicates a chapter 173 00:10:25.584 --> 00:10:28.784 to talk about social morality 174 00:10:28.784 --> 00:10:30.334 The key to social morality 175 00:10:30.334 --> 00:10:33.884 is The Golden Rule 176 00:10:33.884 --> 00:10:39.381 As Jesus said in the Sermon on the Mount, 177 00:10:39.381 --> 00:10:41.631 ‘So whatever you wish that others would do to you, 178 00:10:41.631 --> 00:10:43.531 do also to them, for this is the Law and the Prophets’ [Matt. 7:12] 179 00:10:43.531 --> 00:10:49.731 This is the Biblical Golden Rule 180 00:10:50.131 --> 00:10:52.031 Meaning, all parts of morality 181 00:10:52.031 --> 00:10:54.131 is condensed in this one verse 182 00:10:54.131 --> 00:10:57.531 Do what you wish others 183 00:10:57.531 --> 00:10:59.631 would do to you 184 00:10:59.631 --> 00:11:02.131 (The Golden Rule) It puts one in others' shoes, 185 00:11:02.131 --> 00:11:04.832 assessing oneself in their stance 186 00:11:04.832 --> 00:11:08.432 Also, doing what one wishes to receive 187 00:11:08.432 --> 00:11:10.632 from the other 188 00:11:11.932 --> 00:11:16.082 completes social morality as Jesus has taught us 189 00:11:16.082 --> 00:11:19.382 This does not only resolve problems 190 00:11:19.382 --> 00:11:21.282 in all interpersonal relationships, 191 00:11:21.282 --> 00:11:26.482 but also restores into the right relationships 192 00:11:26.482 --> 00:11:29.682 Jesus did not talk about a new morality 193 00:11:29.682 --> 00:11:31.182 or a new order 194 00:11:31.182 --> 00:11:34.932 It is rather Jesus reminding us 195 00:11:34.932 --> 00:11:41.032 the moral principle that has been there in history 196 00:11:41.032 --> 00:11:45.532 The Golden Rule has appeared in the OldTestament, 197 00:11:45.532 --> 00:11:49.932 in Deuteronomy and other historical contexts, 198 00:11:50.382 --> 00:11:52.432 and this is a foundational principle 199 00:11:52.432 --> 00:11:54.582 underlying God’s laws 200 00:11:54.582 --> 00:11:56.682 In terms of social morality, 201 00:11:56.682 --> 00:12:00.732 Lewis discusses the relationship between church and the world 202 00:12:01.182 --> 00:12:06.482 He critically examines the idea that 203 00:12:06.482 --> 00:12:09.082 the Church should lead the world 204 00:12:09.082 --> 00:12:11.132 Whether it is true depends on 205 00:12:11.132 --> 00:12:14.332 the intended meaning behind the statement 206 00:12:14.332 --> 00:12:17.232 For it to be true, 207 00:12:17.232 --> 00:12:22.182 The Church should lead the world by Christians 208 00:12:22.182 --> 00:12:24.782 fulfilling their proper roles in all areas of the society, 209 00:12:24.782 --> 00:12:31.232 economic, social, and cultural, as practical examples 210 00:12:31.232 --> 00:12:33.382 of Christ in action 211 00:12:33.382 --> 00:12:37.182 When the Church (or clergy) becomes politicized 212 00:12:37.182 --> 00:12:42.032 and tries to lead the world through political agendas, 213 00:12:42.032 --> 00:12:43.932 then it is misguided 214 00:12:44.532 --> 00:12:47.083 Lewis comments on clergies, 215 00:12:47.083 --> 00:12:52.783 Pastors are not called to advance political agendas 216 00:12:52.783 --> 00:12:58.933 they are set apart to care for matters 217 00:12:58.933 --> 00:13:03.833 essential to humanity as eternal beings 218 00:13:03.833 --> 00:13:08.133 Perhaps it was what happened in Lewis' time, 219 00:13:08.936 --> 00:13:11.236 but Lewis disagrees that clergies 220 00:13:11.236 --> 00:13:15.233 leading political programs 221 00:13:15.233 --> 00:13:19.033 or saying political agendas is necessarily leading the world 222 00:13:19.233 --> 00:13:24.933 Abraham Kuyper of the Netherlands, though he served as Prime Minister 223 00:13:24.933 --> 00:13:30.183 and entered politics as a Member of Parliament, 224 00:13:30.583 --> 00:13:32.133 not as a pastor anymore 225 00:13:32.133 --> 00:13:34.633 but to lead the world as a politician 226 00:13:34.633 --> 00:13:37.333 When he was no longer Prime Minister, 227 00:13:37.333 --> 00:13:40.683 the Dutch Reformed Church 228 00:13:40.683 --> 00:13:43.183 invited him to return as a pastor 229 00:13:43.183 --> 00:13:44.883 He declined, 230 00:13:44.883 --> 00:13:47.383 not out of disregard for the pastoral role, 231 00:13:47.383 --> 00:13:51.483 but because he was committed 232 00:13:51.483 --> 00:13:54.433 to making a difference as a politician 233 00:13:54.433 --> 00:13:56.483 This was not from political ambition, 234 00:13:56.483 --> 00:13:59.433 but in response to a practical need 235 00:13:59.433 --> 00:14:01.683 He was a great politician, 236 00:14:01.683 --> 00:14:04.333 better than any pastors 237 00:14:04.333 --> 00:14:09.083 Thus, leading society through pastors presenting 238 00:14:09.083 --> 00:14:11.833 political programs is not the Church’s role 239 00:14:12.283 --> 00:14:16.883 Instead, skilled and capable Christians in various fields, 240 00:14:16.883 --> 00:14:21.583 in economics, society, culture, 241 00:14:22.533 --> 00:14:25.133 education, and more 242 00:14:25.133 --> 00:14:28.684 This is how the Church leads the world 243 00:14:28.684 --> 00:14:33.084 Finally, he outlines what he believes to be 244 00:14:33.084 --> 00:14:35.434 the most Christian vision for society 245 00:14:35.434 --> 00:14:38.084 Let me read some quotes 246 00:14:38.434 --> 00:14:41.084 The Christian vision he proposes is 247 00:14:41.084 --> 00:14:44.084 a society where ‘those who do not work do not eat’ 248 00:14:44.084 --> 00:14:48.484 This is a biblical view of labor 249 00:14:48.484 --> 00:14:54.734 'The society refrains from excessive luxuries and advertising, 250 00:14:54.734 --> 00:14:58.734 and there is no place for arrogance or vanity, 251 00:14:58.734 --> 00:15:04.934 and instead people respect and obey duly appointed officials' 252 00:15:04.934 --> 00:15:07.234 'It is a place filled with song and joy, 253 00:15:07.234 --> 00:15:11.184 where worry and anxiety are seen as evils to be avoided' 254 00:15:11.484 --> 00:15:14.034 A healthy Christian society is not marked by gloom or sorrow 255 00:15:14.034 --> 00:15:18.284 but rather by joy and celebration, 256 00:15:18.284 --> 00:15:22.584 living a life that embraces festivity 257 00:15:22.834 --> 00:15:24.234 Economically, 258 00:15:24.234 --> 00:15:26.884 't is a society where loans are given without interest' 259 00:15:26.884 --> 00:15:29.434 A society rife with usury 260 00:15:29.434 --> 00:15:33.234 and people burdened by excessive interest rates 261 00:15:33.234 --> 00:15:35.634 is not a Christian society 262 00:15:35.634 --> 00:15:39.334 Finally, he emphasizes charity, 263 00:15:39.334 --> 00:15:43.184 underscoring the importance of compassion and sharing 264 00:15:43.184 --> 00:15:45.384 For charity, 265 00:15:45.384 --> 00:15:49.884 It must be a society 'that gives a little beyond what is comfortable,' 266 00:15:49.884 --> 00:15:55.634 offering more than it readily can' 267 00:15:55.634 --> 00:16:00.584 And he writes a sharp insight 268 00:16:00.584 --> 00:16:05.084 'If charitable giving never strains or limits 269 00:16:05.084 --> 00:16:09.334 the household budget, then one is likely giving too little' 270 00:16:09.334 --> 00:16:12.585 'There should be things you wish to do 271 00:16:12.585 --> 00:16:14.835 but can’t due to charity' 272 00:16:14.835 --> 00:16:17.935 True charity isn’t simply giving what’s left 273 00:16:17.935 --> 00:16:19.435 after doing everything you wish to do 274 00:16:20.388 --> 00:16:22.538 There should be things you can't do 275 00:16:22.538 --> 00:16:25.438 due to charity in this Christian society 276 00:16:25.438 --> 00:16:30.038 Thus, he presents a vision of a society 277 00:16:30.038 --> 00:16:33.639 embodying true social morality, 278 00:16:33.639 --> 00:16:37.439 grounded in the 'Golden Rule' found in Matthew 7:12 279 00:16:37.439 --> 00:16:39.439 In the Old Testament, 280 00:16:39.439 --> 00:16:44.039 this aligns with the society fitting the moral laws 281 00:16:44.039 --> 00:16:48.689 that God provided in the law as shown in Deuteronomy 282 00:16:48.689 --> 00:16:54.239 Even in those who do not believe in Jesus Christ, 283 00:16:54.239 --> 00:16:57.589 such traits are evident in humanity, 284 00:16:57.589 --> 00:17:00.189 created in God’s image 285 00:17:00.189 --> 00:17:03.339 For those transformed in Jesus Christ, restoration comes 286 00:17:03.339 --> 00:17:05.485 even more swiftly, 287 00:17:05.485 --> 00:17:08.885 revealing something more beautiful, 288 00:17:08.885 --> 00:17:12.335 such as a more moral society 289 00:17:12.335 --> 00:17:14.135 This is why 290 00:17:14.135 --> 00:17:16.335 we need the grace of the gospel 291 00:17:16.335 --> 00:17:20.335 This is the approach Lewis takes 292 00:17:28.385 --> 00:17:29.385 Chapter 2 The Cardinal Virtues 293 00:17:29.385 --> 00:17:31.035 1. Seven virtues 1) Cardinal: Prudence, Temperance, Justice, Fortitude 294 00:17:31.035 --> 00:17:32.635 2) Theological: Faith, Hope, Love 295 00:17:32.635 --> 00:17:34.285 2. Four Cardinal Virtues 296 00:17:34.285 --> 00:17:35.885 1) Prudence: Practical wisdom 297 00:17:35.885 --> 00:17:37.535 2) Temperance: Not abstinence, 298 00:17:37.535 --> 00:17:39.135 but moderation 299 00:17:39.135 --> 00:17:40.735 3) Justice: More than legal justice 300 00:17:40.735 --> 00:17:42.335 4) Fortitude: Courage against danger 301 00:17:43.385 --> 00:17:44.385 Chapter 3 Social Morality 302 00:17:44.385 --> 00:17:46.385 1. The Golden Rule [Mat. 7:12] Being in others' shoes 303 00:17:46.385 --> 00:17:47.885 2. Church Leads the World? 304 00:17:47.885 --> 00:17:49.385 Christian community practicing the Golden Rule in society 305 00:17:49.385 --> 00:17:50.885 NOT the church or pastors presenting political programs 306 00:17:50.885 --> 00:17:52.385 3. Lewis' Ideal Christian Society? 307 00:17:52.385 --> 00:17:53.885 1) Those who don’t work don’t eat 308 00:17:53.885 --> 00:17:55.385 2) Without excessive luxuries or advertising 309 00:17:55.385 --> 00:17:56.885 3) Without show-offs or boastful people 310 00:17:56.885 --> 00:17:58.315 4) With charity a little more than what’s comfortably affordable